Player of the Year:
Ruben Alcala-Brookhaven
Pitcher of the Year:
Michael Miles-Cumberland County
Two-Way Player of the Year:
Joe Barberio-Niagara County
1st Team:
| Mike Flemming | Erie | So | C |
| Tommy Dunleavy | Northampton | So | DH |
| Jose Castillo | Cedar Valley | Fr | INF |
| Brian Forbes | Herkimer | So | INF |
| Dan Sullivan | Oakton | So | INF |
| Dylan Scaranda | Cumberland County | So | INF |
| Matt Pietsch | Minnesota State | So | OF |
| Kyle Hawes | Northern Essex | So | OF |
| Billy Rogers | Cedar Valley | So | OF |
| Yadiel Rolon | St. Cloud Tech | Fr | P |
| Nick Evangelista | Rowan Gloucester | So | P |
| Joseph Valentino | Suffolk County | So | P |
| Trent Shoulders | Coastal Bend | So | CL |
2nd Team:
| Brandon Ernst | Northampton | Fr | C |
| Tanner Cooper | Finger Lakes | So | DH |
| Vincent Chiarenza | Niagara County | So | INF |
| Leo Romero | Northern Essex | So | INF |
| Dillion Eatman | North Lake | So | INF |
| Ryan McIsaac | Cumberland County | So | INF |
| Brandon Kruzinski | Herkimer | So | OF |
| Alex Whipple | Erie | So | OF |
| Luis Massa | St. Cloud Tech | So | OF |
| Tyler Stacy | North Lake | So | P |
| Noah Weber | Northampton | So | P |
| Drew Schultz | Delta | So | P |
| Skylar Mursu | Minnesota State | So | CL |
3rd Team:
| Michael Iacobellis | Nassau | So | C |
| Alex Gattinelli | Rowan Gloucester | So | DH |
| John Marion | Surry | Fr | INF |
| Will Lawrence | Niagara County | So | INF |
| CJ Gantz | Northampton | So | INF |
| Will Funk | St. Cloud Tech | Fr | INF |
| TJ Scuderi | Brookdale | Fr | OF |
| CJ Peechatka | Northampton | So | OF |
| Cody Windisch | Richland | So | OF |
| Eric Heatter | Brookdale | So | P |
| Zac Cummins | Rock Valley | Fr | P |
| LUIS SAVIGNE | Oakton | So | P |
| Dale Stanavich | Herkimer | Fr | CL |